How to Make a Poke Cake

How to Make a Poke Cake recipe shows how to make a jello poke cake with fun colors and flavors, perfect for a rainbow-themed celebration.

I’m pretty obsessed with making simple cake recipes. And in my opinion, poke cakes are at the top of the list. What other dessert out there can have holes poked into it and filled with delicious and tasty flavors and come out looking as beautiful as this.

I love how moist this jello poke cake is and that’s probably one of the other biggest reasons that people tend to crave these types of cakes. Not to mention the delicious and light topping – it makes for a fun and tasty treat! 

While jello poke cake tend to be really popular during the summer months, they’re great to bake up and enjoy all year long! I also love how easily the flavors can be switched out to make it taste new time and time again. 

How to Make a Poke Cake

Even though there’s nothing really “unicorn” about this cake, it’s what it reminds me of so that’s where the name comes from. Unicorns are magical and fun and all things beautiful and to me, that encompasses this boxed cake mix recipe. 

Not only that but since you get to use a boxed cake mix as the starter, the rest of making and baking this cake is a breeze! Dare I say that it’s one of the easiest cake recipes out there? 

I could totally see this simple rainbow cake is used for birthday parties, fun overnight guests, or just a fun way to bring a smile to someone’s tasty and tummy! 

What is a poke cake?

A poke cake is is a cake with holes poked in it right after it comes out of the oven, usually with the thin handle of a wooden spoon or chopstick.

Next, a liquid of some sort, like jello, or a syrup, like chocolate, caramel or strawberry, are added to fill the holes to add a little extra flavor in almost every bite. 

This is such a fun activity for the kids to join in on as well. They’ll be able to poke holes and pour in the different jello mixtures and see the colors form! 

This is such an easy jello poke cake recipe.

Choosing colors to be used in a unicorn or rainbow poke cake can be serious business too. I always laugh remembering how much thought my son would invest in choosing flavors and colors of jello for cakes we would make together.

The great part about poke cake is that there really is no magic way to make it happen. Whatever works for you is going to be the best way to make this cake. 

Ingredients Needed to Make Rainbow Cake from a Boxed Cake Mix 

• Box white cake mix
• Water
• Vegetable oil
• Eggs
• Strawberry jello mix
• Grape jello mix
• Blue raspberry jello mix
• Cool Whip or another whipped topping
• Food coloring and sprinkles

Hacks for Making Poke Cake

This jello poke cake isn’t hard to do at all but since I’ve made it a ton, I thought I’d share some of my poke cake tips and hacks. 

Make certain that you spray the cake pan really well with cooking spray so that the cake doesn’t stick once baked. This will ruin the overall look if it crumbles or sticks when you try to serve. 

Once you’ve baked the cake and allowed it to cool completely, you’ll want to use a wooden spoon handle to poke holes in the cooled cooked cake.

Make certain that you leave spaces so that the colors that you’re going to add will still separate and not bleed together. Although if they do, it’s not the end of the world.

You’ll be using a jello mixture that is flavored to add to the poked holes so you can use the ones that I’ve used in the recipe or branch out and choose your own. 

Make certain that you leave a bit of the jello mixture to use in a bit so refrain from pouring all of it into the holes.

Chilling this cake in the fridge is not an option! Super important step so be certain to do it! 

The leftover jello can be used to flavor the whipped cream topping or to even make some fun jello jigglers to put on the top of the cake or have as a fun snack option. 

More Fun Topping Ideas for Boxed Cake Mix Poke Cake 

If you’re not a fan of whipped cream, don’t force it. You can easily top with a frosting or even powdered sugar as well.  I also love to mix in some sweetened shredded coconut as well and have that as a fun topping.

Let the kids dye the shredded coconut with green food coloring and it will look like grass! 

How to store poke cake

You’re going to have to keep this poke cake stored in the fridge. This cake is meant to be kept cold due to the whipped topping and jello flavoring added. 

Just be certain to have a lid on it and keep it stored in the fridge until you’re ready to eat.

This cake can be frozen as well if you’re unable to eat it within about 3 days of making it. 

Enjoy the simplicity of this simple cake recipe. It brings a ton of flavor to the table because of the different flavors of jello mix that you’re adding.

Feel free to change up what you’re adding to change up the taste and colors. I’ve done all blue, all green, and all yellow as well! This poke cake is so versatile you can really have fun with it! 

More Cake Recipes

• Raspberry Jello Poke Cake Recipe
• Chocolate Mint Poke Cake
• Caramel Infused Chocolate Cupcakes
• Red Velvet Swirl Bundt Cake
• Best Easy Bundt Cake Recipes
• Mini Pound Cakes with Strawberry Glaze