Butterfinger Shot

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

The irresistible Butterfinger shot is a creamy, chocolatey concoction that's creamy and buttery, and a perfect addition to your party or sipped as an after-dinner treat. It's inspired by the popular Butterfinger candy bar with the flavors of butterscotch, coffee, and Irish cream flavors.

Two Butterfinger shots on table with spirits in background.

This unique cocktail was inspired by this smoked old-fashioned drink that I just love. My orange gin and tonic is a bit of a spin on the ever favorite original. This chocolate mojito with mint is also a quite tasty drink that you're sure to love.

Why You Will Love This Butterfinger Shot

Simple But impressive! It's easy to make and perfect for parties.
Tastes Just Like the Candy Bar. Using an exact combination of ingredients to mimic this popular candy.
All-Occasion Cocktail. The candy-inspired taste of Butterfinger shots makes them a wonderful party drink and conversation starter or an ideal after-dinner sweet treat for any occasion.

Ingredients

This rich, delicious, chocolate and peanut butter-flavored cocktail only takes a handful of simple ingredients to make, and you can find them pretty much anywhere.

Kahlua: This coffee-flavored liqueur adds a rich depth to your shot.
Butterscotch Schnapps: Butterscotch gives this Butterfinger shot its distinctive candy bar flavor.
Bailey's Irish Cream: Adds creaminess, a touch of whiskey flavor, and richness.
Garnish: Chocolate, butterscotch, or caramel syrup along with butterfinger candy bars or crushed peanuts work great to garnish the rim of the glasses.

The full ingredient list and quantities of each one are in the recipe card.

Substitutions and Variations

Don't have the correct ingredients on hand? Or want to change something up? Here are some helpful tips for you to change these Butterfinger shots.

Kahlua: You can use Tia Maria or any other coffee liqueur.
Peanut Butter Liqueur: Try another nutty liqueur like Skrewball peanut butter whiskey to create a unique and flavorful twist on a shot.
Shake It: Instead of layering, add the ingredients to an ice-filled shaker. Give it a good shake and then strain the mixture into the prepared shot glass.

How to Make Butterfinger Shots

This decadent cocktail is as easy as it is delicious. It only takes a few minutes and a few simple steps, and you'll have delicious cocktails that everyone will be clamoring for.

The recipe highlights are listed here, but you can find the exact instructions in the recipe card at the end of the post.

Dip a shot glass into a bowl of chocolate syrup.
Then dip it into crushed Butterfingers.

Shot glass with chocolate syrup on the rim.

Shot glass rimmed with chocolate syrup and crushed Butterfinger.

Pour the Kahlua into the glass first.
Add the butterscotch schnapps for the second layer by pouring it over the back of a spoon into the glass.

Kahlua being poured into shot glass rimmed with chocolate syrup and crushed Butterfinger.

Closeup shot of Kahlua being poured into shot glass rimmed with chocolate syrup and crushed Butterfinger.

Finish with a layer of Bailey's pouring it over the inverted spoon.

Adding the Bailey's to the top of the glass.

⭐️ Hint: Easily alter the proportions of the ingredients to suit your taste. If you prefer a stronger coffee flavor, use a bit more Kahlúa. If you have a sweet tooth, increase the amount of butterscotch schnapps.

If you love recipes like this, you may also enjoy this Kahlua hot chocolate. My Key Lime Pie Shot is so good. It actually really tastes like the dessert. My Breakfast Shot is a great way to start the day and this Sweet Tart Shot is a favorite with those who remember the classic candy.

If you're looking for one to drink during the Christmas holidays, check out my Three Wise Men Shot. It's got quite the kick and is really loved by many a party goer.

Closeup shot of Buttefinger shot next to Butterfinger pieces.

What to Serve with Butterfinger Shots

Add Some Toppings: Consider some whipped cream on top for a creamy finish with a sprinkle of cocoa powder or cinnamon for an extra kick, and some finely grated chocolate or caramel drizzle for added sweetness.

Grazing boards with dips or spreads, cheeses, cured meats, spicy pickles, and crackers work well with these shots.
Fried foods also work well. Try fried potato skins, onion rings, or deep-fried pickles.
Healthier options include a vegetable tray with a variety of fresh fruits and vegetables along with some garlic hummus and buffalo chicken spinach dip.
Party appetizers like air fryer Buffalo chicken wings, fajita nachos, and the like work well with these shots, as well.

Tips

Serve immediately. This recipe makes a single shot and looks best served right away!
Adjustable flavor. You can use more or less of any of the liqueurs to create a drink to suit your taste.
Use good-quality butterscotch schnapps, like DeKuyper or Hiram Walker, for the best flavor.
Chill ahead of time. Be sure all the ingredients are chilled before making the shot.
Garnish the glass: It adds an attractive and festive finish to the glass and enhances the flavor of the drink.

This shot pairs well with my Irish cream cake. Give it a try, you won't regret it.

FAQ

Do you have questions about Butterfinger shots? Here are some of the most commonly asked questions about this Butterfinger shot recipe.

Can I make it non-alcoholic?

Yes, you can make a non-alcoholic version by substituting the alcoholic ingredients with flavored syrups and cream, such as butterscotch syrup, chocolate syrup, and heavy cream.

Can I serve it as a cocktail instead of a shot?

Absolutely! To serve it as a cocktail, simply increase the quantities of the ingredients and serve it in a larger glass.

Do I have to layer the shot?

Not at all. Layering the shot is strictly for presentation. You can simply mix the ingredients if you prefer.

How can I make even layers in this shot?

Invert a small spoon over the base Kahlua layer. The spoon should be just above the Kahlua but not touching it. Then, slowly pour in the next layer of your shot.

Two butterfinger shots in glasses on the table.

More Cocktail Recipes

Do you like fun mixed drinks? Here are some recipes you may also like to try.

Ready to get cooking? Remember that you can print this recipe if you would like.